JCPenney Beats Amazon by 45 Points: The 7 Stores With the Biggest Black Friday Discounts in 2026

Black Friday 2026 falls on Friday, Nov. 27, and this year one store is beating the rest by a distance that is hard to believe. WalletHub surveyed over 2,250 deals from 11 of the biggest US retailers’ 2026 Black Friday ads to find out where the real discounts live. The best Black Friday deals can save up to 89% this year, but the gap between the best store and the rest is the story.

JCPenney tops the ranking with an average discount of 74.33%. Amazon, the store most shoppers check first, sits in ninth place at 29.25%. That is a gap of 45.08 points. Put simply, the average advertised deal at JCPenney cuts almost three quarters off the price, while the average Amazon deal cuts less than a third. As WalletHub analyst Chip Lupo put it, “Knowing which retailers actually offer significant deals compared to their normal prices can save you a lot of time and prevent buyer’s remorse.”

Macy’s takes second place at 56.50%, and Target takes third at 38.47%. Kohl’s follows at 37.47%, then Best Buy at 30.88%, Walmart at 30.57%, BJ’s at 30.51%, The Home Depot at 30.33%, Amazon at 29.25%, and Newegg at 23.15%. The full WalletHub ranking, reported by Florida Today, shows the same pattern in every category. A few stores discount deeply. Most discount modestly.

Timing matters too. Amazon Black Friday Week began Nov. 19, and Walmart and Target sales are already live. Cyber Monday follows on Nov. 30. That gives you a full week to shop with a plan instead of grabbing whatever flashes across your screen first. The plan below is simple. Start with the store that leads for the thing you actually want to buy, and work down the list from there. Keep the ranking open while you shop, and check each store in order, so the deepest discount gets the first chance at your money.

The top 10 stores, ranked by average Black Friday discount

Average advertised discount in the WalletHub 2026 study of over 2,250 deals.

JCPenney 74.33%Macy’s 56.50%Target 38.47%Kohl’s 37.47%Best Buy 30.88%Walmart 30.57%BJ’s 30.51%Home Depot 30.33%

Amazon ranks ninth at 29.25%, and Newegg tenth at 23.15%. The leader beats Amazon by 45.08 points.

1. JCPenney: The Runaway Winner at 74.33%

Sparkling jewelry on velvet trays in a bright store display case

JCPenney is not just first. It is first by a huge margin. Its average discount of 74.33% sits nearly 18 points ahead of second place Macy’s at 56.50%. No other store in the study comes close. If you shop at only one store this Black Friday, the numbers say this is the one.

Jewelry is where JCPenney shines brightest. Its average jewelry discount is 74.55%, the best of any store in any category in the study. Macy’s is the only other store near it, at 70.02%. If a necklace, a ring, or a watch is on your gift list, start here and compare everything else against it.

Clothes and accessories are strong here too, at 46.01% on average. That trails Macy’s, but it still beats Target at 39.74% and Walmart at 36.77%. The smart move is to check jewelry first, then clothes, and let the ranking set your order. Shop the deepest discount first, while sizes and stock are still there. A store that averages 74.33% off does not discount every single item that deeply, so check the price on the exact piece you want before you celebrate.

2. Macy’s: Your Best Bet for Clothes and Toys

Neat racks of colorful winter coats, sweaters and dresses in a bright clothing department

Macy’s earns second place overall with an average discount of 56.50%, and it leads two whole categories outright. For clothes and accessories, its average discount is 65.02%, the best in the study. Nobody else tops 50% in that category. JCPenney is next at 46.01%, then Target at 39.74%.

Toys are the other Macy’s strength. Its average toy discount is 59.86%, again the best in the study. Kohl’s is second at 47.35%, and Target is third at 40.59%. If your list is heavy on gifts for kids, Macy’s deserves the first look, not the last.

Jewelry is strong here as well, at 70.02% on average. That is second only to JCPenney at 74.55%. The pattern is clear. Macy’s is the store for the gift list itself: clothes for the adults, toys for the kids, and jewelry for the big present. Start with the category where it leads, and you are shopping where its discounts run deepest.

Who leads each category

Category Leader Average discount
Clothes and accessories Macy’s 65.02%
Phones and computers Best Buy 30.88%
Toys Macy’s 59.86%
Jewelry JCPenney 74.55%

Macy’s leads two categories. JCPenney leads jewelry by a wide margin. Best Buy leads phones and computers.

3. Target: The Strong All-Rounder

Bright store shelves with folded clothes, home goods and gift displays under holiday garland

Target takes third place overall at 38.47%, and its strength is balance. It never leads a category, but it is near the top in all of them. That makes it the best single stop when your list mixes clothes, toys, and home goods, and you want one trip instead of four.

Clothes and accessories average 39.74% off at Target, third best in the study behind Macy’s at 65.02% and JCPenney at 46.01%. Toys average 40.59% off, again third, behind Macy’s at 59.86% and Kohl’s at 47.35%. Those are solid numbers across the board, not a spike in one aisle.

Target’s sales are already live, so you do not have to wait for Friday, Nov. 27 to start. Check the categories where it ranks third, and compare them against the leaders before you buy. If Macy’s has the coat you want at a deeper cut, buy it there. If Target wins on the toy, buy it here. The ranking works best when you let each store win its own category, and Target wins plenty of second rounds.

4. Kohl’s: The Toy Aisle Dark Horse

Cheerful toy shelves with plush animals, colorful gift boxes and wooden building blocks

Kohl’s ranks fourth overall at 37.47%, just behind Target. Its real story is toys. Kohl’s averages 47.35% off toys, second only to Macy’s at 59.86%. It beats Target at 40.59%, Walmart at 37.40%, and Amazon at 30.89% in the same aisle.

That makes Kohl’s the backup plan every toy buyer needs. If Macy’s sells out of the toy on your list, Kohl’s is the next best place to look, and its average discount is still far above Amazon’s. Check Macy’s first, Kohl’s second, and only then move down the list.

Kohl’s overall average of 37.47% also beats every store below it, including Best Buy, Walmart, and Amazon. It is a steady performer rather than a one-category wonder. For a mixed gift list with toys at the center, it earns its place in the top four. The gap between Kohl’s and Target is tiny, at less than one point, so treat them as near equals and buy the toy where the price on your exact item is lower.

5. Best Buy: The Tech Stop

Bright electronics department with televisions, laptops and headphones on clean display tables

Best Buy ranks fifth overall at 30.88%, and it leads the category that matters most for tech buyers. Its average discount on phones and computers is 30.88%, the best in the study. Amazon is next at 28.08%, then Walmart at 25.81%, Costco at 24.98%, and BJ’s at 24.20%.

The gap at the top of tech is small, so a little comparison shopping pays off here. Best Buy leads, but Amazon is only a few points behind. If the exact laptop or phone you want is cheaper at one store, buy it there. The ranking tells you where to look first. It does not replace checking the price on the exact model you want.

Best Buy is a focused pick. Go there for phones and computers, and shop the other categories elsewhere. Its overall average matches its tech average exactly, at 30.88%, which tells you its deals are steady rather than spectacular. For tech, steady and first is enough. Start your tech search here, then check Amazon at 28.08% and Walmart at 25.81% on the same model, and buy whichever store gives you the lower final price.

6. Walmart: The One-Stop Shop

Wide warehouse store aisle with bulk household goods and gift boxes stacked on tall shelves

Walmart ranks sixth overall at 30.57%, and its value is convenience. Its sales are already live, and it is competitive in every category without leading any of them. Clothes and accessories average 36.77% off, toys average 37.40% off, and phones and computers average 25.81% off.

Compare those numbers with the leaders before you settle. Macy’s beats Walmart on clothes by a wide margin, at 65.02% against 36.77%. Macy’s also beats it on toys, at 59.86% against 37.40%. Best Buy beats it on phones and computers, at 30.88% against 25.81%. Walmart wins when you want everything in one order.

That is the right way to use Walmart this year. Buy the everyday items and the gifts where it is close to the leaders, and buy the big-ticket categories where the leaders win. One cart can still save you money, as long as the deepest discounts come from the stores that lead each category. With sales already live and Cyber Monday on Nov. 30, you have time to split the list across stores instead of settling for one average discount on everything.

7. BJ’s: The Bulk-Buy Surprise

Bulk store shelves with gift baskets, folded blankets and holiday decor

BJ’s rounds out the top seven at 30.51% overall, just a fraction behind Walmart at 30.57%. It is the surprise entry on this list, because warehouse clubs are not the first place most shoppers think of for Black Friday. The numbers say they should be.

Phones and computers average 24.20% off at BJ’s, fifth best in the study. That trails Best Buy at 30.88% and Amazon at 28.08%, but it still beats plenty of big names. If you already shop at BJ’s for bulk household goods, its Black Friday tech deals are worth a look before you buy the same item elsewhere.

BJ’s earns its spot by being steady across the board, much like Walmart. Its overall average of 30.51% sits above The Home Depot at 30.33%, Amazon at 29.25%, and Newegg at 23.15%. It will not beat JCPenney or Macy’s on any single category, but it belongs on the list, and it belongs on your route if you are already a member. Check its tech prices against Best Buy and Amazon on the same model, since the gap at the top of that category is small and a few points can mean real money.

How to use this ranking without getting burned

  • Shop by category, not by store. Start with the leader for what you want to buy.
  • Check the price history of the exact item before you buy, so you know the discount is real.
  • Compare the same item at two or three stores. A high average discount does not mean the lowest price on your item.
  • Watch doorbusters closely. The deepest deals often carry limited stock and sell out fast.
  • Buy the big gifts first, while sizes and stock are still available, then fill in the rest.

The ranking gives you a clear order of business. JCPenney first for jewelry and the deepest average discount in the study, at 74.33%. Macy’s first for clothes at 65.02% and toys at 59.86%. Best Buy first for phones and computers at 30.88%. Target, Kohl’s, Walmart, and BJ’s fill in the rest, each with an overall average between 30.51% and 38.47%.

Remember what the percentages actually measure. They are averages across the advertised deals WalletHub studied, not a promise that every item in the store is cut by that much. A store can lead the ranking and still price one item higher than a rival. That is why the checklist above matters. Check the price history, compare the exact item, and watch the doorbusters, and the averages will work in your favor instead of against you.

Amazon still has its place, but the numbers say it should not be your first stop. At 29.25% it ranks ninth, behind eight other stores, and it trails JCPenney by 45.08 points. Use it to compare prices on the exact item you want, and buy where the discount is deepest. Black Friday is Friday, Nov. 27, with Cyber Monday on Nov. 30, and the sales are already running. Start with the leaders, check the price before you buy, and let the ranking do the hard work for you.

We craft smart, actionable content about money, health, style, and travel that fits real life. No fluff, just practical wisdom delivered with charm and backed by data.

Stay in the loop

Get weekly stories that actually fit real life — no spam, just value.


© 2026 Live Our Narrative. All rights reserved.

Made with Love
Live Our Narrative
Logo